What if Your Son Wants to Live with His Dad?

Can a child really decide where they live? Let's explore times that a child can decide where to live, important age minimums, and measuring their best interests.
DivorcePlus Decorative Image - Teenage boy pointing at something on light blue background
  • Understand Your Child’s Voice: There is no set age where a child can decide which parent they want to live with, but their preferences are given more consideration as they grow older, usually around the age of 12 or 13. 
  • Navigating Preferences and Refusals: If your child expresses a preference to live with one parent over the other, look to understanding their feelings and not your own.
  • Making Decisions with Your Child’s Best Interest in Mind: When a child expresses a desire to live with one parent, open and honest communication is key. 

Understanding Your Child’s Choice

When the marriage breaks or couples separate, one of the most difficult questions that arises is whether my son can choose who he will stay with as he develops. The answer to this question is nuanced and varies depending on several factors including the age of the child involved, specific family circumstances and local family law in their state. This blog post aims at demystifying this complex issue by offering advice and resources for parents who are going through such a tough time.

Does Age Matter?

All states allow judges to consider children’s custody preferences provided it shows sufficient maturity. Additionally, some states require judges take into consideration the wishes expressed by children who are found mature enough.

However, what constitutes “maturity” for a child varies across jurisdictions; instead, judges have been granted discretion over this determination based on individual circumstances.

For example, California, New Mexico and West Virginia provide that 14 years old represents adequate maturity, while other states like, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Tennessee and Texas – presume that children aged above 12 years are sufficiently capable of expressing meaningful preferences.

As a general rule, courts give more serious consideration to a child’s choice as s/he gets older. In any state, judges are more likely to listen to the opinions of a child who is over the age of 14. The situation is different for younger kids, particularly those whose ages are in single digits. However, the middle group of children within this age range may be allowed to express their wishes in certain states based on specific circumstances; again, it depends on maturity.

What if your child does not want to live with one parent?

In many cases, children may express a desire to stay with one parent and not the other. These types of situations can be very sensitive and emotional. If your child shows any reluctance or even refuses to live with one parent it is important that you handle it with care. Allow them to talk openly with you so they can freely express themselves without fear of being judged harshly or suffering retaliation of any kind.
To enable your child air their concerns without feeling intimidated you could even consider using a qualified professional such as counsellor that will remain neutral during this process.

What do I do if my son wants to live with his dad?

What if a child chooses to live with his father as opposed to living with you? This should take into account your son’s feelings and the bigger picture. Open, honest, and respectful conversation is vital. Understand why he thinks that way and decide whether it would be better for him to change the current arrangement of custody. However, this is also a good opportunity to engage a coach who can provide guidance that suits your family’s particular needs in such cases; don’t be afraid. Nonetheless, these considerations must put your child’s interests first, looking for the best solution that promotes his happiness and well-being.

Should You Ask a Child Who They Want to Live With?

Forcing children to choose between their parents after separation or divorce can be very unfair because they end up feeling torn between two adults. It entails walking on eggshells while managing post-divorce family relationships. Let’s discuss why and how one should ask this sensitive question:

Emotional Toll: Requesting youngsters directly what choice they would want isn’t a cakewalk for them emotionally speaking. Firstly, they might feel guilty causing anxiety or worry about saying something wrong that could hurt either parent in some way or being responsible for causing pain on any side among other reasons. In dealing with such difficult emotions children in emotional development stages may become stressed in behaving out of behavior assumption changes.

Creating Room for Self-Expression: Rather than putting the burden of making choices in the hands of the child, it is important to create an environment where children feel safe talking about their living situations. Open-ended inquiries regarding home comfortability, happiness can be used instead of forcing kids into choosing one parent over another.

The Role of Professional Guidance: In some instances involving a third party for the child to rely on – like a parenting coordinator or counselor may assist the child in finding their voice and articulating mature decisions. In addition, they may offer parents valuable advice on how to deal with their child’s changing preferences in a constructive way. Since this can help the child to vent without fear of judgment or retaliation, and it gives them an opportunity to discuss whatever feelings they might hold in private.

Child’s Age and Maturity: As discussed, the age and maturity level of a child are relevant factors when it comes to how much weight should be given to their preference regarding custody. But at the end of it all, parents should consider desires expressed by their children through the lens of the child’s ability to express them.

Best Practices for Parents: Parents should strive to maintain open communication with each other and work together in making decisions that will reflect the interests of their children. They need to listen to what the child is expressing as their needs.

Moving Forward

There is no simple answer when trying to navigate through the maze of custody issues and living situations after divorce. Every family situation is unique; what is good for one child may not be appropriate for another. Keep talking openly with your child and let him know you support him no matter what happens next; do not forget seeking professional assistance whenever necessary!

DivorcePlus offers a range of resources whether you need guidance to navigate through this transition:

• Discover more information about divorce and custody at Divorce 101.

• Find professional services that work for your family’s needs.

• Meet with an online divorce coach for personalized guidance through emotional and practical aspects of your custody arrangement.

• Talk to a lawyer when you need legal advice.

But don’t be afraid to ask for help because it is important that you make informed choices that keep your child’s best interests in mind. With proper support and tools, you will be able to manage this difficult period and chart a way forward that suits your family the most.

Recent Divorce 101 Articles
DivorcePlus Decorative Image - Fight, senior or angry couple argue with stress for marriage

Dealing with Divorce and a Sick Spouse

Any marriage can be pushed to the breaking point by the challenges of living with a chronically ill spouse. If you are thinking about divorce under these circumstances, you’re most likely wrestling with guilt, confusion, and the need for direction.

Read More »
DivorcePlus Decorative Image - Victorian gas lamp

Understanding Gaslighting: Its Effect and the Ways to Break Free

The trauma associated with gaslighting is substantial, affecting individuals on both psychological and physical levels. Victims often experience erosion of self-trust, heightened anxiety, isolation, and long-term emotional distress. Understanding the signs and impacts of gaslighting is crucial for anyone who finds themselves or someone they know in such a distressing situation.

Read More »
DivorcePlus Decorative Image - Silhouette angry sad boyfriend girlfriend quarreling screaming on family problems in evening

Understanding Emotional Abuse

Emotional abuse is characterized as a pattern of harmful behaviors where one person repeatedly undermines another’s mental and emotional well-being. While physical abuse leaves visible marks, emotional abuse hurts the victim’s psyche through damaging acts that have severe psychological effects.

Read More »